Serving Weld County
Updated October 2026.
The McCutcheons Addition runs along the north side of La Salle, the blocks between 2nd and 5th Avenues that were platted first as the McCutcheons Addition and then as the much larger McCutcheons 2nd Addition — at 7.4 acres, the biggest recorded historic plat inside La Salle town limits. Because it was filed in pieces over decades and never built out all at once, the housing here is the most varied in town. Recorded sales in the plats run from a 1918 two-bedroom on 3rd Avenue at $305,000 and a 1946 three-bedroom on 4th Avenue at $469,000 to a 2000-built office building on North 2nd Street at $415,000, with mid-century ranches filling the middle — a 1948 house on 2nd Avenue sold at $275,000 and a 1950 on 2nd 1/2 Avenue at $299,500. An active listing in October 2026 was a 1952 four-bedroom on 5th Avenue at $285,000. There is no HOA in the residential plats, and the North 2nd Street frontage carries the light commercial and office uses that serve the north end of town. What makes the McCutcheons Addition practical is the walk. Main Park — the LaSalle Day park at North 2nd Street and 3rd Avenue — sits inside the neighborhood, the Maurice McMahan Community Center and Memorial Park are a few blocks south on Todd Avenue, and Pete Mirich Elementary is at 300 1st Avenue. US 85 is a couple of minutes away, putting Greeley about 10 minutes east, and the same highway reaches Fort Collins and I-25. Schools are Weld County RE-1 (Valley): Pete Mirich Elementary (PK–6), Valley Middle School (7–8) at 300 2nd Avenue, and Valley High School in Gilcrest.
The McCutcheons Addition is La Salle's north-side historic district — the McCutcheons and McCutcheons 2nd Addition plats between 2nd and 5th Avenues, a century of housing from 1918 bungalows to 2000s infill with resales from $275,000 to $469,000.
The McCutcheons 2nd Addition covers 7.4 acres — more recorded plat area than any other historic addition inside La Salle town limits.
Recorded sales span a 1918 bungalow at $305,000 to a 1946 home at $469,000, so buyers can shop very different houses on the same blocks.
Main Park at North 2nd Street and 3rd Avenue — home of the town's LaSalle Day celebration — is a walk from most of the addition.
Updated October 2026. Active-listing figures for La Salle come from the live IRES MLS feed on the Northern Colorado market report.
Bungalow, Ranch, Cottage, Contemporary
Explore homes for sale and the full neighborhood guide for La Salle, Colorado — including market trends, schools, and community information for the entire La Salle area.
Ready to buy or sell in McCutcheons Addition? Contact SAA Homes today at (970) 999-1407 or visit our office at 3665 John F Kennedy Parkway, Suite 210, Fort Collins, CO 80525. Our local experts know McCutcheons Addition and every neighborhood in Northern Colorado.
Schwartz and Associates, Coldwell Banker Realty — serving home buyers and sellers across Fort Collins, Loveland, Windsor, Greeley, and all of Northern Colorado.